| Date of match | Type of match | Name of team | Name of team | Score | Attendance |
5 November 1887 | FA Cup 2nd round | Darlington | Elswick Rangers | 4-3 | - |
26 November 1887 | FA Cup 3rd round | Darlington | Shankhouse | 0-2 | - |
3 October 1891 | FA Cup 1st qualifying round | Darlington | Port Clarence | 3-0 | - |
24 October 1891 | FA Cup 2nd qualifying round | Darlington | Scarborough | 13-1 | - |
5 December 1891 | FA Cup 4th qualifying round | Darlington | Middlesbrough Ironopolis | 0-3 | - |
29 October 1892 | FA Cup 2nd qualifying round | Darlington | Darlington St Augustines | 5-1 | - |
10 December 1892 | FA Cup 4th qualifying round | Darlington | Stockton | 1-5 | - |
1894-95 season | FA Cup 1st qualifying round | Darlington | Darlington St Augustine's | 7-0 | - |
1894-95 season | FA Cup 2nd qualifying round | Darlington | Stockton | 2-0 | - |
1894-95 season | FA Cup 3rd qualifying round | Darlington | Middlesbrough | 0-1 | - |
21 December 1907 | International Amateur match | England | The Netherlands | 12-2 | 3,000 |
3 January 1934 | Division Three (North) Cup 1st round | Darlington | Gateshead | 1-1 | 1,720 |
21 March 1934 | Division Three (North) Cup quarter-final | Darlington | York City | 4-3 | 2,000 |
16 April 1934 | Division Three (North) Cup semi-final | Darlington | Wrexham | 3-1 | 3,823 |
7 October 1936 | Division Three (North Cup 1st round replay | Darlington | Gateshead | 3-0 | 1,730 |
7 April 1937 | Division Three (North) Cup quarter-final | Darlington | York City | 3-2 | 1,044 |
14 April 1937 | Division Three (North) Cup semi-final | Darlington | Southport | 2-2 | 2,030 |
3 March 1985 | Freight Rover Trophy Northern section 1st round 2nd leg | Darlington | Halifax Town | 7-0 | 765 |
26 March 1985 | Freight Rover Trophy Northern section 2nd round | Darlington | Lincoln City | 1-3 | 1,648 |
14 January 1986 | Freight Rover Trophy Northern section 1st round Group 2 | Darlington | Chesterfield | 2-0 | 1,057 |
27 March 1986 | Freight Rover Trophy Northern section quarter-final | Darlington | Mansfield Town | 3-0 | 1,425 |
1 May 1986 | Freight Rover Trophy Northern section semi-final | Darlington | Bolton Wanderers | 0-3 | 3,771 |
2 December 1986 | Freight Rover Trophy Northern section 1st round Group 6 | Darlington | Rochdale | 2-2 | 766 |
5 December 1987 | Sherpa Van Trophy Northern section preliminary round Group 5 | Darlington | Chesterfield | 2-1 | 888 |
26 January 1988 | Sherpa Van Trophy Northern section 2nd round | Darlington | Rotherham United | 3-2 | 1,354 |
16 February 1988 | Sherpa Van Trophy Northern section quarter-final | Darlington | Halifax Town | 1-2 | 1,510 |
